The headline of the essay by Yale Professor Samuel Moyn reads: “Professors are Too Old: The Academy’s Gerontocracy Problem is Worse Than Anyone Admits” (Chronicle of Higher Education, April 23rd online).
Professor Moyn may have a point. Consider Carleton College in Northfield, Minnesota, where the faculty recently took a vote of no confidence in its President, Alison Byerly. The motion passed by an overwhelming margin. A week prior to the vote, President Byerly had announced a new policy that requires all deceased faculty members at Carleton to retire.
Nelson Filshoot, Professor of Anthropology and Chair of Carleton’s Faculty Senate, declared the policy to be “outrageous and discriminatory. This is yet another example of oppression perpetuated by the ‘League of the Living’, who deny rights to those who no longer breathe.
“In 2026, there’s absolutely no reason that a dead faculty member can’t continue to thrive in the classroom. We have AI, which can provide lectures and assignments, and teaching assistants, who can grade students’ work. Where’s the problem?
“Please let our deceased colleagues keep serving the institution. It’s the right thing to do, and President Byerly knows it. There’s a lot more to being a professor than prancing around campus, looking all ‘alive’.”
Carleton’s Board of Trustees will decide the President’s fate at a closed meeting on May 28th.










